Best Korean Eyeliner for Oily Lids and Long Days

The best korean eyeliner for oily skin here is the lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 Survival Penliner, because its 0.1mm brush tip lays down a hairline stroke that sets fast enough to stay where you put it. If you'd rather build soft definition than draw one hard black line, the Ash Brown version of the same pen is the smarter buy at 0.99 g of product. Neither is right for everyone. If you never wear liner past mid-morning, or your lids stay matte on their own, this whole category is money you don't need to spend. Start with a setting step instead.

Best korean eyeliner for oily skin at a glance

How I screened this shortlist down to seven

I lined up every listing side by side and compared what each one actually publishes: tip width, product weight, count, dimensions, shade name and format. That is a narrow set of numbers, and it is the honest limit of what anyone can say from a listing page.

Two things shaped the final seven.

1. Format spread. Three liquid pens, two pencils, one powder, one remover. Oily lids are a whole-routine problem, not a single-product one.
2. Published figures over adjectives. A listing that gives me 0.25 g and 5.59 x 0.51 x 0.59 in tells me more than one that says "long-lasting" four times.

What got cut in my head, and why it matters to you: anything whose only argument was the phrase "waterproof" repeated in different capitalisation. Every liner in this set claims waterproof or oil-proof wear. That claim is the floor, not a differentiator.

One important note on the search itself. Not every pick here is an eyeliner, and no product in this group publishes a formulation detail that proves it performs differently on oily skin than on dry. The oil-resistance language is the manufacturer's, and it appears on nearly every liner sold. So I've treated "oily skin" as a routine question rather than a product claim, and two of the seven picks exist to handle the parts of that routine a pen can't.

Why does eyeliner slide on oily lids?

Sebum is a solvent. It creeps up from the lash line and along the crease, and it works underneath a line that has already dried. That's why liner rarely smears sideways on an oily lid. It transfers upward, printing a faint second line on the mobile lid or under the brow.

Most guides for the best korean eyeliner for oily skin compare waterproof claims. Waterproof is not the same as oil-proof, and it isn't what decides this. The real criterion is thinner: how narrow a line can you lay down, and how fast does it set before it moves?

Here's the logic. A hairline stroke has less product to migrate. The lilybyred pens claim a 0.1mm brush; Brenqe claims 0.01mm on a felt tip. Both are far finer than the line a gel pencil draws. Less pigment sitting on skin means less to lift when oil arrives.

Set time matters just as much. Both lilybyred listings say the formula dries in seconds and grips skin, and the Ash Brown listing describes "skin-gripping adhesion". Those are claims, not measurements. But format supports them: a thin liquid film dries faster than a waxy pencil deposit, which stays soft and movable for far longer.

• Thin line, fast set: liquid pens
• Thicker line, slower set: gel and wax pencils
• Reduces the oil arriving in the first place: a setting powder underneath

Pen, gel pencil or powder: which format holds?

Format is the fork in the road, so pick it before you pick a brand.

Liquid pens. Three of the seven picks are pens. You get precision and speed, and you give up forgiveness. A liquid line dries where you put it, which is the whole point and also the problem when your hand slips. The lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 at 0.6 g and its Natural sibling at 0.99 g both sit in the highest price positions in this set, and the Natural is the priciest liner of the group.

Gel pencils. The ETUDE Proof 10 is the only gel pencil here. Gel gives you a softer, smokier line you can smudge on purpose, and its listing claims a waterproof film polymer that withstands sebum. At 0.25 g it holds the least product of any liner here, which is worth knowing before you commit.

Wax pencils. The Produco set is a pair of pencils built for under-eye work rather than the lash line. Different job entirely.

Powder. Not a liner at all. The SKINFOOD Peach Cotton Multi Finish Powder is 5 g of loose setting powder, and its role is to sit under everything else.

If you're new to this and want one purchase, buy a pen and accept a learning curve. If you want to look decent on day one, buy the gel pencil. The pen gets sharper results by week three.

1. lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 Survival Penliner — Best overall

A 0.1mm brush tip and a fast-setting black liquid make this the most reliable pick here for a line that has to survive a shiny lid.

Best for: sharp wings on lids that get shiny by noon Skip it if: you want a soft brown rather than flat black

What separates this pen from the rest of the group is the combination of a stated 0.1mm brush and a single flat black shade, 01 Matt Black. Nothing else here promises a line that fine in a true black. Brenqe claims a finer 0.01mm tip, but that's a felt tip rather than a brush, and felt spreads as it wears down.

lilybyred says the pen uses an ink tank system for continuous flow, and that it resists water, sweat and oil. Treat those as the brand's claims. What I can confirm from the listing is the physical package: 0.6 g of product in a barrel measuring 0.79 x 5.51 x 0.79 in, model L065A. That is a slim pen you can hold like a pencil, which is what makes fine control possible.

The listing also says warm water removes it, which is unusual for a liner making waterproof claims. Useful if you don't want to buy a dedicated remover.

The trade-off: this is the second-most-expensive liner here, and 0.6 g is less product than the Natural version's 0.99 g. You pay a premium position for one shade.

Pros:

• 0.1mm brush tip claim, finest brush in this set
• True flat black in 01 Matt Black
• Slim 0.79 in barrel for pencil-style grip
• Removes with warm water, per the listing
• Sells faster than the Natural version here

Cons:

• Only 0.6 g, the second-smallest liner load here
• Second-highest price position of the seven picks
• Single shade, no brown option in this listing
• Just two sellers stock it
• Oil resistance is a brand claim, not a published measurement

2. lilybyred AM9 to PM9 Survival Penliner Natural — Best for pros

Same 0.1mm brush, more product at 0.99 g, and an ash brown pigment you build up stroke by stroke instead of committing in one pass.

Best for: layered, natural definition and tightlining Skip it if: you need one stroke of opaque black

This is the pick for anyone who already knows how they like their eyes to look. The shade is 02 Ash Brown, and lilybyred describes the pigment as layerable, so intensity comes from how many passes you make rather than how hard you press. The brand also says the ash tone neutralises redness and yellow undertones around the eye.

It carries 0.99 g, the largest liner load in this group and 65% more than the black version's 0.6 g. Same claimed 0.1mm elastic brush, and the listing specifically mentions tightlining as a use case. Model L211A.

For oily lids, the buildable approach has a real advantage: you can lay one thin pass, let it set, then add a second only where you want depth. Thin layers set faster than one thick stroke. That is the whole argument for this pen over a pencil.

The cost is bluntness. Ash brown will never give you a graphic black wing, and it's the most expensive liner in this set. It also sells the slowest of the seven picks, so it's the least conventional choice on the shelf.

Pros:

• 0.99 g, the most product of any liner here
• Layerable ash brown pigment for controlled intensity
• Same claimed 0.1mm brush as the black version
• Listing names tightlining specifically
• Ash tone offsets redness around the eye, per the brand

Cons:

• Highest price position of all seven picks
• Brown won't deliver a graphic black line
• Slowest seller in this group
• No published barrel dimensions, unlike the black version
• Buildable colour means more passes, so more time at the mirror

3. Produco [thebom] AegyoSal Eyeliner Under-Eye Enhancing — Runner-up

Two pencils in one box, built for under-eye aegyo-sal shading rather than the lash line, with a sharpener included.

Best for: under-eye aegyo-sal shading with a second shade on hand Skip it if: you want a crisp upper-lash line

This is the only multi-pack in the group: 2 count, Volume Beige plus Shadow Brown. The pairing is the point. Beige lifts the area directly under the lower lash line, brown drops a soft shadow below it, and together they create the puffy under-eye look Korean makeup calls aegyo-sal.

Produco describes the formula as fallout-free and smudge-proof, and calls it multi-use across eyeshadow, eyeliner, highlighter and shading. The box measures 0.71 x 2.87 x 6.61 in and includes a sharpener, which matters because the listing warns the product may break if you twist out too much at once.

Here's where I'd temper expectations for oily skin. The under-eye area is where transferred liner shows up worst, and a beige pencil sitting in that zone can shift with the rest. The listing publishes no weight and no formulation detail, so there's nothing here proving it grips better than any other wax pencil.

Its real advantage over the pens: it's the cheapest way in this set to get two coordinated shades, and it sells briskly. The trade-off is that it can't draw the fine upper line the pens can.

Pros:

• Two coordinated shades in one 2-count box
• Sharpener included in the package
• Third-cheapest pick of the seven
• One of the faster sellers in this group
• Multi-use across liner, shadow and highlight, per the brand

Cons:

• Not built for a crisp upper-lash line
• No published weight or product volume
• Listing warns the pencil may break if over-twisted
• Under-eye placement is the hardest zone on oily skin
• Pencil format sets far slower than a liquid pen

4. ETUDE Proof 10 Gel Pencil Eyeliner — Best for beginners

A creamy gel pencil with a sharpener in the base, forgiving enough that a wobbly first attempt still looks deliberate.

Best for: first-timers who want a smudgeable line they can fix Skip it if: you want a hairline flick

Forgiveness is the feature nobody advertises, and it's why this is where I'd start a beginner. A gel pencil goes down soft. If your line is uneven, you smudge it into a smoky one and nobody knows. Do that with a liquid pen and you have a grey smear on your lid.

ETUDE says the gel texture draws a precise line with less effort, and that a waterproof film polymer withstands both water and sebum. Sebum gets named explicitly, which none of the other liner listings here do. The pencil measures 5.59 x 0.51 x 0.59 in, holds 0.25 g, and the listing notes you can sharpen the tip using the sharpener in the bottom for a finer line. Model 650003206.

The catch is that 0.25 g. It's the smallest published liner load in this set, less than half the black lilybyred pen's 0.6 g, and sharpening consumes product. This is also the only pick in the group with a single seller listed, and it moves the slowest of the three liner formats here by a wide margin.

Against the pens, it loses on line width. Against the pencils, it wins on the lash line.

Pros:

• Gel texture blends, so mistakes become smoky liner
• Sharpener built into the base
• Listing names sebum resistance directly
• Full dimensions published at 5.59 x 0.51 x 0.59 in
• Mid-range price position, cheaper than either pen

Cons:

• Only 0.25 g, the smallest liner load here
• Sharpening burns through that small amount faster
• Can't match a 0.1mm brush for a fine wing
• Single seller listed
• Slowest-selling liner of the three formats in this set

5. Brenqe Ultra Thin Liquid Eyeliner — Best budget pick

The cheapest pick here and the only felt tip, with a claimed 0.01mm point that's the finest number published in this group.

Best for: trying the felt-tip pen format cheaply Skip it if: you want published weight and dimension figures

If you've never used a pen liner and don't want to spend up front, this is the one to test the format with. It's the cheapest of the seven picks by a clear margin, and it's the only felt tip in a set otherwise split between brushes and pencils.

Brenqe claims a 0.01mm flexible felt tip, quick-drying and smudge-proof wear, and specifically says it avoids transfer "even on oily eyelids". The listing also claims resistance to sweat, rain and humidity, and says an oil-based remover takes it off without rubbing. All manufacturer language. The shade is listed as 1#Black, 1 count.

Now the honest part. This listing publishes less than any other pick here: no weight, no dimensions, no model number. You get a count and a colour. That's it. The 0.01mm figure is also worth reading carefully, because felt tips blunt with use in a way brush tips don't, so a hairline point on day one is a wider point by week four.

Against the lilybyred pens it gives up the brush and the published specs. What it offers instead is the lowest cost entry into this format, which for a first pen is a fair trade.

Pros:

• Cheapest of all seven picks
• Claimed 0.01mm tip, finest figure in this set
• Only felt-tip option here
• Listing names oily eyelids directly
• High-pigment black, per the brand

Cons:

• No published weight, dimensions or model number
• Felt tips widen as they wear, unlike brush tips
• Single seller listed
• Needs an oil-based remover, per the listing
• Thinnest specification sheet of any pick here

6. SKINFOOD Peach Cotton Multi Finish Powder 5g — Best for heavy use

Not a liner, but 5 g of loose sebum-control powder that goes on the lid before liner and does the job no pen can do.

Best for: setting the lid before liner goes on Skip it if: you are shopping for liner alone

Most shoppers miss this step, and it's the one with the biggest effect on how long a line lasts. Oil that never reaches the surface can't lift your liner. A thin dusting of powder across the lid before you draw gives the liquid a drier surface to grip.

This one holds 5 g in a 2 x 2 x 0.8 in compact. The listing describes it as a loose powder with delicate particles for a light, clear finish without the dryness typical of powders, and the product name calls out peach extract and calamine for sebum control. Treat the sebum-control mechanism as the brand's positioning rather than a measured result.

It's the second-cheapest pick here and the fastest-selling of all seven, which tells you plenty of people are already using it.

The obvious limitation: it draws no line. Buying this alone leaves you with nothing on your lashes. It's also a face powder rather than an eye product, so the 5 g will disappear faster than 5 g dedicated to lids only.

Pros:

• 5 g of loose powder in a compact 2 x 2 x 0.8 in case
• Second-cheapest of the seven picks
• The fastest-selling pick in this group
• Addresses oil at the source, before liner goes on
• Doubles as a face setting powder

Cons:

• Not an eyeliner, so it can't work alone
• Only one feature bullet published on the listing
• No shade range beyond the single finish listed
• Face-sized use will drain 5 g quickly
• Sebum control is brand positioning, not a stated measurement

7. Illiyoon Gentle Deep Eye Makeup Remover — Best premium

A 4.73 fl oz bi-phase remover that breaks down waterproof liner without the scrubbing that makes the problem worse tomorrow.

Best for: taking waterproof liner off without scrubbing Skip it if: you only wear a light pencil line

Removal is where oily-skin routines quietly fall apart. Scrubbing a waterproof line off the lash line irritates the area, and irritated skin produces more oil. Every liner in this set makes waterproof claims, and Brenqe's listing states outright that it needs an oil-based remover.

This one is a 4.73 fl oz bi-phase formula, oil and water in separate layers that you shake to combine. Illiyoon says the micro-particle formula breaks down waterproof makeup without oily residue or blurred vision, and describes it as ophthalmologist tested and safe for sensitive eyes. The brand also lists it as vegan-certified, fragrance-free, and made without nine specified ingredients including cyclopentasiloxane. Model 111271243. The stated method: shake, apply to a cotton pad, hold over closed eyes for a few seconds, then wipe.

It's the largest volume of anything in this set by a wide margin, and the highest price position of all seven picks.

The trade-off is category. This isn't eyeliner, and if you wear the ETUDE gel pencil lightly, a regular cleanser will probably handle it. The listing also publishes no dimensions and no weight, so you're buying on volume alone.

Pros:

• 4.73 fl oz, the largest volume in this set
• Bi-phase oil and water formula for waterproof liner
• Ophthalmologist tested, per the listing
• Fragrance-free and vegan-certified, per the brand
• Removes the need for rubbing at the lash line

Cons:

• Highest price position of all seven picks
• Not an eyeliner, so it adds to your total spend
• Overkill for a light pencil line
• No published dimensions or weight
• Requires cotton pads, an ongoing extra

What the listings do not tell you about oily skin

This is the honest limit of what I can tell you from listing data, and it's worth being clear about it.

No product here publishes a test result on oily skin. Not one. "Oil-proof", "withstands sebum" and "even on oily eyelids" all appear in feature copy, and feature copy is written to sell. ETUDE names a waterproof film polymer, which is at least a mechanism rather than an adjective, and Brenqe names oily eyelids specifically. Neither publishes a number behind it.

What the listings also don't give you:

• Shade ranges. Each liner listing here covers one shade, or two in the Produco set.
• Tip material for the lilybyred pens. The Natural version says "elastic brush"; the black version just says brush.
• Wear-time figures. No listing states hours of wear anywhere in this group.
• Ingredient lists. Only the Illiyoon remover names what it excludes.
• Warranty. Nothing in this set publishes one, which is normal for cosmetics.

So how do you judge a liner I haven't covered? Look for a published tip width in millimetres, a stated product weight in grams, and a named mechanism rather than an adjective. Those three things separate a listing that tells you something from one that just shouts. And when a claim about oily skin appears, check whether a number sits next to it.

The three-step routine these picks build

Choosing the best korean eyeliner for oily skin is really choosing a sequence, not a single tube. Here's the order I'd run.

1. Set the lid first. Dust the SKINFOOD Peach Cotton Multi Finish Powder across the mobile lid and lash line before anything else. Its 5 g goes a long way at this thickness.
2. Draw thin, then build. One pass with a fine tip. Let it set. Add a second pass only where you want more depth. Both lilybyred listings say the formula sets in seconds, which is what makes this workable.
3. Remove without rubbing. Hold the Illiyoon remover on a soaked pad against closed eyes for a few seconds, then wipe once. The stated hold-then-wipe method exists so you don't have to scrub.

Two extra notes. Skip mascara on the lower lashes if your under-eye area transfers, because lower-lash mascara and shifted liner compound each other. And if you're using the Produco beige pencil under the eye, set it with a whisper of the same powder afterward.

The verdict

The lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 Survival Penliner is the pick I'd hand to most people asking about the best korean eyeliner for oily skin. A claimed 0.1mm brush lays the thinnest black line in this group, the 0.79 x 5.51 x 0.79 in barrel gives you real control, and warm water takes it off. It sells faster than its own sibling here, and it does the core job without asking you to learn a new format.

Two conditions flip that recommendation. First, if you want brown rather than black and you like building intensity in layers, take the AM9 to PM9 Survival Penliner Natural instead. It carries 0.99 g against the black version's 0.6 g and names tightlining specifically, which is a genuine advantage for anyone working close to the lash line.

Second, if you've never drawn a line with a liquid pen, buy the ETUDE Proof 10 Gel Pencil Eyeliner first. It holds only 0.25 g, and it can't match a 0.1mm brush for sharpness, but a gel line you can smudge into shape is worth more than a liquid line you can't fix. Its exact advantage is recoverability.

And whichever liner you pick, the 5 g SKINFOOD powder underneath will do more for wear time than switching brands ever will.

FAQ

Is Korean eyeliner worth it for oily lids?

Korean eyeliner is worth it for oily lids mainly because of tip width, not formula magic. The lilybyred pens claim a 0.1mm brush, which lays down less product than a standard pencil, and less product means less to migrate. No listing here publishes an oily-skin test result, so treat the oil-resistance wording as the brand's claim and judge on line thinness instead.

Which pick gives the most product for the money?

The most product for the money comes from the AM9 to PM9 Survival Penliner Natural at 0.99 g, though it also holds the highest price position in this set. The black Survival Penliner carries 0.6 g, and the ETUDE Proof 10 gel pencil just 0.25 g. If you count volume across all seven picks, the 4.73 fl oz Illiyoon remover is by far the largest.

Does a liquid pen or a gel pencil last longer on oily skin?

Whether a liquid pen or gel pencil lasts longer comes down to set time. Liquid dries into a thin film within seconds, per both lilybyred listings. Gel stays soft and movable much longer, which is what lets you blend it. ETUDE does name a waterproof film polymer that withstands sebum. For pure staying power, the pen format has the structural edge.

lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 or the Natural version: which should I buy?

Between the Am9 to Pm9 and the Natural version, shade decides it. The black 01 Matt Black gives a graphic, one-pass line and publishes full barrel dimensions of 0.79 x 5.51 x 0.79 in. The 02 Ash Brown Natural holds more at 0.99 g, builds intensity in layers, and names tightlining. Want definition rather than a statement wing? Take the Natural.

What mistake do people make buying eyeliner for oily skin?

The mistake people make buying eyeliner for oily skin is treating "waterproof" as the deciding spec. Every liner in this set claims it, so it separates nothing. The two things that actually change wear time are a genuinely fine tip and a setting step underneath, like the 5 g SKINFOOD powder. Skipping the powder and blaming the liner is the usual error.

Start with the lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 Survival Penliner and the 5 g SKINFOOD powder together, in that order on your face. That pairing costs less than most people spend replacing liners they blamed for a problem the powder would have solved. Draw one thin pass, wait, then add a second where you want it. If your line still shifts by afternoon, the fix is thinner strokes, not a stronger formula. And when the day ends, don't rub. The reason the black lilybyred pen leads this group isn't a claim on its box. It's that a 0.1mm brush puts less on your lid to begin with.

Last updated: September 7, 2026. Product availability re-checked.

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.